Showing posts with label Robert Spencer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Spencer. Show all posts

Tuesday, 17 April 2012

Projecting Further

So, presumably we must add, to those hate-mongers Robert Spencer, et al. who are held partly responsible for the monster Breivik:
  • World of Warcraft - because Breivik played it a lot. I mean, a lot! And it's violent. In that you can kills things. Like almost every other computer game.
  • Clint Mansell - because Breivik liked one of his tracks - it gave him courage, or something.

Don't hold your breath. Well, WoW might get a bit of heat, like computer games do every now and then. And Clint might be feeling a little hot under the collar, having his name written in the same sentence as the Norwegian mass murderer.

But as others are already pointing out, the focus will ultimately fall on those who agree with much of Breivik's view of the decline of the West and the danger of Islam, no matter how much they reject his belief that murder is the answer.

UPDATE: Two more sources of influence in the life of Breivik:

  • Al Qaeda
  • Wikipedia

I'm not sure which scares me more.

Monday, 1 August 2011

The Art of Projection

The argument by those explaining why the likes of Robert Spencer et al are responsible for the murders in Norway runs as follow:
  • Their articles are filled with hate.
  • The murderer read their articles.
  • Therefore the murders were part-caused by the writers.
We know the second statement to be true; many articles were referenced in the "manifesto".

The first, alas, is never supported with any evidence; they take the "hate" part for granted. Is it hate because they don't agree with what is written? Is what's written erroneous? It's irrelevant, as neither of those constitute hatred.

And yet, without evidence of hatred, the argument falls apart. It won't stop its repetition of course. And these champions of what is good and just continue their attack.

I particularly enjoyed the irony of the commenter who told Pamela Geller she "didn't deserve the life you have." (link lost) And the ever upright BBC got comments from a "Norwegian philosopher" (Lars Gule, a Professor, no less), criticising Robert Spencer for writing about Islam, at no point telling its eager and faithful audience that Gule had been convicted of carrying explosives intended for a terrorist act.

Lars Gule has said that, "while he once believed that it was possible to create a societal revolt without violence, he now believed that the use of weapons is needed in order to cure injustices because no one gives up his rights without a fight." (source) That appears to be the same conclusion the Norway murderer came to.