Sunday, 27 May 2018
Skills versus Skillz
This has upset some players. In the many gripes I've read about the game and "missed opportunities" (of which it sounds like there are several, such as lack of ship types, lack of interesting missions, etc.), the wish is that players can acquire more powerful weapons, faster ships, etc., by progress and experience in the game.
One commenter said (slight paraphrase, as I can't remember the exact wording - it was a YouTube comment I don't care to hunt down again), "There's no difference between someone with 1000 hours on the game and someone with only 3."
I haven't played the game yet. I've watched it played, in person and in videos. If I get to play it, I will undoubtedly be terrible at it, as I've never been a great games player, and mastered/completed very few over the years (I made perfect runs on an old LED Pac-Man clone, called "Puck Monster", and completed Head Over Heels on the ZX Spectrum, but that's about it).
But I do hope I would improve over time. I seriously hope I would be better after 1000 hours than I would after 3. I would understand the mechanics, the limitations, how far I needed to be from someone to hit them with a sword or pistol, how to steer a ship so it wouldn't hit rocks, how to dock at a jetty, and so on.
Which makes me wonder about those wanting their 1000 hours of skills supplemented further with powerful stats - shots they fire do more damage, their characters and/or ships can take more damage before being disabled. It's most likely they just the types of people that like to swagger around a digital world they have spent a long time in as if they own it. "This is my territory. I have a history here, and you are new. Be nice to me or suffer the consequences." Or they like to kill other players and inconvenience them as easily as possible, and putting in the time on the game rewards them with this ability - they have "earned" that right.
But I also wonder - are there people around now who know longer recognise (or never did) that you acquire a skill by genuinely working at it? (Yes, I know, the skills acquired in games don't really deserve that label, but stick with the point.) Has the point been lost that you master something over time through effort - you don't automatically get rewarded just because you put in the time? It reminds me of the recent comparison between Japanese(?) youngsters making what looked like giant ball bearings out of balls of crunch up foil - they polished them, sanded them, until they were smooth and reflective - while Western youngsters munched on washing machine pods. One took time, effort and skill, to create something interesting to behold (while not especially useful), while the other was hazardous to health and could be accomplished by someone equally well whether they had been on the planet 3 hours or 200,000 hours.
Tuesday, 23 April 2013
Of Marathons and Terrorists
Izzard says, "He’s one of the greatest people who’s lived because he’s not a saint."
Ok-ay. A rare admission that Mandela was a terrorist? Otherwise what's the point of saying it? Most of us aren't saints. Does that make us all great? (With Izzard's "belief in human beings", perhaps that is so.)
"I would say Nelson Mandela isn’t special, but what he’s made himself do is special. He spent all that time in prison - to come out that calm, with that generosity of spirit...this guy needs to be celebrated."
Now I'm confused - he came out of prison and wasn't annoyed. Should he have been annoyed? Wasn't he a terrorist after all? Why does he get to be celebrated again?
Now, let's be clear, Izzard may be being cut short by the editor's knife, and he may have explained himself much better in the original interview. Let's hope so, anyway.
At least, after having to cut his 27 marathons in 27 days for Mandela's 27 years of imprisonment short due to ill health, Izzard still feels he witnessed enough in South Africa to comment on improvements in that troubled country.
"It’s definitely in a better place...There’s still a good deal of separation, but the black community are the people in political power."
Now, that "but" in the clause seems to be Izzard suggesting the black community being the ones in political power is a Good ThingTM. Is he really suggesting there's a right and wrong colour for the people in the political class of a country? I wonder if he popped champagne when the position of leader of the most powerful nation was filled by a black man, or if he's reserving that for a Native American to get the job.
"The fact that there was a black South African doctor giving me good advice in a hospital that was quite far out in the Eastern Cape, very much in the countryside... that just wouldn’t have happened before."
Sounds like South Africa is finally catching up to the NHS.
Of course, if black people have political power in South Africa, they lose their "free from racism" card. Normally only white people can be racist, you see, because you have to have both prejudice and power. I guess the whites in SA can no longer be racist. That's a nice turnaround for that country. Well done Mandela. Now I see why Izzard thinks you should be celebrated.
Friday, 11 May 2012
Homophobia - the Latest Benchmark
Tuesday, 24 April 2012
...And Physically Superior too!
The voice gave little away, but the killer’s eyes, posture and physique spoke volumes. As the days wore on and he became unsettled by the prosecution’s questioning, white specks of dandruff flecked Breivik’s dark jacket, beads of sweat glistened on a face pockmarked by acne, and a motionless comb-over grew more slicked and gleaming.So, not only is Breivik a killer, but he's spotty, greasy and got dandruff. I bet he's a doody-head as well.
When they were telling us he was blonde and blue-eyed, the media never completed the picture of what an ugly git he was too.
Thursday, 19 April 2012
Morally and Intellectually Superior
When not reminding us he's very right-wing, the reporters quoted in the Telegraph seem to be trying to outdo themselves in moral superiority.
To be honest, unless you've slaughtered large numbers of people, you really don't have to try so hard to make out you're "better" than Breivik. But, since no one seems able to legally kill him, I guess they'll have to make do with mocking him. Hell, he played World of Warcraft for a year, the sad Billy No-Mates. (I did rather like the report that the judge asked if it was a violent game - rather reminded me of an old Not the Nine O'Clock News sketch.)
Now, hearing he got his facts from Wikipedia and wished to commemorate the Gates of Vienna battle, the Telegraph's chief foreign correspondent David Blair soon put him in his place:
As someone who is old enough to have learned his history from lessons and books, as opposed to Wikipedia, I would suggest that the Battle of Lepanto of 1571 was a far more significant event. This clash at sea destroyed Turkish naval supremacy in the Mediterranean and began the long retreat of the Ottoman Empire.Battle of Lepanto: 1,070,000 hits on Google. Gates of Vienna: 2,590,000 hits on Google. Significance? Not a lot - using Google to assess importance is about on a par with using Wikipedia for serious study. Then again, feeling you need to show you're intellectually superior to a mass-murdering World of Warcraft expert strikes me as equally vacuous.
Blair also reported how the prosection had cleverly got Breivik to say he should be executed:
And, as the piece de resistance, Breivik recommended his own execution. So it was that the defendant was drawn into hanging himself.But Breivik said he wants to either be executed (by a court he does not recognise the authority of, and therefore perhaps would feel he is being put to death for his cause) or set free (by a court he would then perhaps feel had come round to his way of thinking). He doesn't want to be locked away (like a common criminal, even if he only gets 21 years). I've read little in the Telegraph to suggest he's tripping himself up in some way, the real meaning of a defendant "hanging" themselves. But what do I know? I've played Xenoblade Chronicles for 80 hours.
Tuesday, 17 April 2012
Projecting Further
- World of Warcraft - because Breivik played it a lot. I mean, a lot! And it's violent. In that you can kills things. Like almost every other computer game.
- Clint Mansell - because Breivik liked one of his tracks - it gave him courage, or something.
Don't hold your breath. Well, WoW might get a bit of heat, like computer games do every now and then. And Clint might be feeling a little hot under the collar, having his name written in the same sentence as the Norwegian mass murderer.
But as others are already pointing out, the focus will ultimately fall on those who agree with much of Breivik's view of the decline of the West and the danger of Islam, no matter how much they reject his belief that murder is the answer.
UPDATE: Two more sources of influence in the life of Breivik:
- Al Qaeda
- Wikipedia
I'm not sure which scares me more.
Monday, 2 April 2012
Could they be fooling themselves?
With special productions in their online and print editions, British media is giving its own account of the military conflict that confronted Argentina and the UK in 1982. (My emphasis)Maybe that's a turn of phrase I'm just not used to, but is it really honest to say that Argentina and the UK were "confronted" by "military conflict", as if such an event was drawn randomly from the Bag of Fate? Has the Buenos Aries Herald forgotten that Argentina started the whole thing by invading the islands? (I understand there was never a formal declaration of war from either side.)
Another odd news story occurred yesterday, making me wonder if it was an April Fool's story. I'm still not entirely convinced. Apparently, following his suspicious landslide victory in the Bradford West election, George Galloway tweeted, "Shattered but happy after the Blackburn triumph."
This does appear to be expose Galloway as caring little for which location he was voted in, as long as he won and now has some power. But he tweeted shortly after, "Nice try. Password now changed," and suggested his account had been hacked.
Really? Wouldn't a hacker have tweeted something a little more...interesting? A little more controversial? It might well be true, and we either have the most uninspired hacker in the world, or the most shrewd. But Occam's Razor suggests to me Galloway is trying to cover up his idiocy. Or does he really believe what he wrote?
Sunday, 19 February 2012
"How can this happen in the 21st Century?"
This idea that, as time goes on, we become superior to everyone before us is little more than ignorance and arrogance.
Wednesday, 7 December 2011
"Forced to Apologise"
It's a phrase I see a lot in the media. I wonder if they use it knowing how ridiculous it sounds, verging on the oxymoronic. You cannot force someone to apologise. If they have to be forced, then they don't mean it.
Perhaps the phrase is meant to convey the subject was blissfully unaware of the hurt they were causing, and an outcry made them see things differently (in which case, it hardly seems forced - more an awakening), or (more likely) this is the media pointing out this person has realised that, unless they go through the motions, they face ruin in whatever fragile bubble of fame, fortune and/or power they find themselves in.
We say to very young children, "Say you're sorry," in what is perhaps an understandable attempt to teach those still stuck at the selfish level of development about the ways of the larger society. But I've also seen pupils in secondary school "forced to apologise": they are sent to the teacher they have allegedly offended to issue a verbal or written apology. It's never worth it.
Melanie Phillips has written about, "a teenage burglar who, asked to write a letter of apology to his victims, wrote instead that he wasn't bothered or sorry at all, and that the burglary was all their fault for leaving their window open. Such incidents suggest that we are dealing with something beyond merely ruthless acquisitiveness and contempt for the law. They suggest a total absence of empathy for another person, which is the basic requirement of morality and, in turn, of a civilised society. They illustrate a brutalisation of humanity."
While I agree with her larger comment, at the very least the burglar was being honest. If you have to ask someone to write a letter of apology, the result will be pointless, regardless of its content. The victims didn't need an apology anyway - they needed financial reparations. "You can stuff your sorries in a sack, mister."
Tuesday, 20 September 2011
The Infallible Argument from Comedy
The non-existence of God was pretty much his theme for the evening, with such evidence offered as the fact God didn't flick off Hitler's head before he did so many terrible things and the fact God didn't show up to congratulate the human race when they reached the Moon.
Instead, Izzard told us he "believes in us!", in human beings, a state often recognised in theology as what happens when people reject the idea of gods - rather than stopping worshipping, they start worshipping themselves, each other or anything else they can find. Believing in the greatness of humans (except members of the BNP, obviously) would, you would think, make Izzard be grateful God didn't flick off Hitler's head - it gave an opportunity to show how great humans can be in the face of evil. As for the Moon, why wouldn't the supposed Creator of the Universe be impressed that, despite all the atrocities humans committed in the 20th Century, they managed to travel a quarter of a million miles (about 0.00000000000000003% of the width of the universe) and back?
I don't know how long celebrities have been using their celebrity status to sound off their views in public, usually demonstrating they have become celebrities by being great at exactly one thing. It's probably always been that way.
"Rock stars: is there anything they don't know?" - Homer Simpson
Of course, there's always Stephen Fry, who is hailed as a celebrity genius. I've heard the guy really is quite smart, but I can't help feeling most people accept his genius because he hosts QI. (Fewer would reach the same conclusion about Richard Whiteley, late host of Countdown, but there you go.)
Now, I'm not really saying celebrities lack the skills to shine in other areas - there are plenty of examples of comedians successfully moving to acting (and plenty of examples of musicians moving unsuccessfully to acting). There are many cases where someone has become famous for something that wasn't necessarily their passion, but gave them the chance to pursue their passion later (though I can't think of an example offhand!).
So it's entirely possible a show-business celebrity can have deep insight into politics, religion, history, etc. But I think many people listen to and take on board celebrity views only because they like their comedy, their songs, their films, etc. It's a lazy way to form an opinion.
Speaking of lazy, I occasionally stumble across one of Tim Minchin's comedy shows being televised. Talk about preaching to the converted. Last night I heard him do his own take on a refrain Ben Elton and Billy Connolly have done in the past. The bit starts off with something like, "Some people don't like my swearing," and ends with the comedian swearing. Tim Minchin's take was to segue from swearing to religion, with the punchline that he was now going to do a song about "anal sex and God", to which he received rapturous applause, before and after said song. (To my ear, the song used the same technique Russell Brand uses: multi-syllabic words disguising themselves as intellectual content.)
Comedians these days are in a particular position of power in espousing their viewpoints - firstly, their occupation literally is standing up, spouting their thoughts unchallenged. Secondly, they usually have a faithful congregation to preach to. Thirdly, and most powerful of all, if anyone does challenge them, the obvious response is, "It's comedy, get over it."
So I really shouldn't have bothered.
Tuesday, 6 September 2011
The Newest Religion
But when I see followers of "scientism" exhibiting such traits, I have to suspect it's an aspect of human nature, rather than an aspect of religions, that is the root cause.
Exhibit A - Physicists: Universe Almost Certainly Not a Hologram
There's something quaint, almost absent-minded professorish, while at the same time exciting, about this investigation into whether the universe might be a hologram. But it's the lead comment I found more intriguing:
The universe, in some ways, is different every day for all of us, regardless what we believe, while in other ways it stays the same. For this commenter, having a "priest" (or, in their terms, a "science god") tell them what their latest experiments lead them to conclude is enough to give them the jollies and feel their universe is different.
Such adoration of knowledge, while commendable to a degree, is disappointing when seen as the pinnacle of man's pursuits. When one tackles a maths textbook at school, maybe it can be said the universe seems a little different each day as one gains understanding. But it doesn't change the fact the answers are already set, in the questions themselves as well as in the back of the book.
Not sure who the dead guy is, though. Could he be talking about Mohammed? That's just mean.
Exhibit B: Ten Things Everyone Should Know About Time
Again, as interesting as the article is, it's a comment that caught my attention:
Steffen Says: "On #9: Also our grandkids won’t live forever. Perhaps they will enjoy a prolonged lifespan and much higher quality of life in old age, but they will not live forever.
"There is a very good reason evolution invented death. The cycle of life and death ensures that a species adapts much better to changing circumstances. Imagine a society where everybody is immortal. It quite inevitably culminates in an ultra-conservative nightmare, where “everything is like it was forever”. Imagine a society where the industry tycoons of the 19th century still own the majority of money and influence.
"[...] I am glad that death exists, and when my time arrives, I will go, to make place for the young generation. They deserve their chance."
I was surprised and glad to read the denunciation that "our grandkids won't live forever," since it's often a staple of scientism that, eventually, we will defeat death through science. I detect a schism, at least two sects within this religion, where one side pursues immortality (often while chiding religious believers for believing such nonsense themselves) and the other acknowledges limits to the reach of science (almost a heresy, surely - the normal interpretation to such limits is that, anything outside the realms of science does not actually exist anyway).
But it was the sentence I've highlighted that stopped me in my tracks for sheer stupidity. Evolution, a mindless concept that rules out any ideas of purpose in anything, somehow has the capacity for invention, and inventing no less a milestone than death itself.
We know from our schooling that evolution takes millions of years (except for those times when it doesn't - another schism, I suspect) to accomplish something (not that it accomplishes - since there's no goal, there's no measure of accomplishment), yet here it cobbled together "death" to ensure our survival.
When did it do this? One hopes from the beginning (whatever that means), otherwise there are beings in existence that have never died, which surely gives an in for more religious ideas.
Monday, 1 August 2011
The Art of Projection
- Their articles are filled with hate.
- The murderer read their articles.
- Therefore the murders were part-caused by the writers.
The first, alas, is never supported with any evidence; they take the "hate" part for granted. Is it hate because they don't agree with what is written? Is what's written erroneous? It's irrelevant, as neither of those constitute hatred.
And yet, without evidence of hatred, the argument falls apart. It won't stop its repetition of course. And these champions of what is good and just continue their attack.
I particularly enjoyed the irony of the commenter who told Pamela Geller she "didn't deserve the life you have." (link lost) And the ever upright BBC got comments from a "Norwegian philosopher" (Lars Gule, a Professor, no less), criticising Robert Spencer for writing about Islam, at no point telling its eager and faithful audience that Gule had been convicted of carrying explosives intended for a terrorist act.
Lars Gule has said that, "while he once believed that it was possible to create a societal revolt without violence, he now believed that the use of weapons is needed in order to cure injustices because no one gives up his rights without a fight." (source) That appears to be the same conclusion the Norway murderer came to.
Sunday, 24 July 2011
Start with a Summary
If non-Islamic terrorists attack the West, it is because of the West.
If Islamic terrorists attack the West, the media will avoid reference to their appearances or beliefs.
If non-Islamic terrorists attack the West, the media will clearly state their hair and eye colour, political and religious beliefs.
If Islamic terrorists attack the West, their actions are in spite of Islam, which is a religion of peace.
If non-Islamic terrorists attack the West, their actions confirm that all religions, particularly Christianity, are vile and violent.
If Islamic terrorists attack the West, you cannot criticise their religion because of a few extremists.
If non-Islamic terrorists attack the West, it was only a matter of time; that's what followers of religion do.
If Islamic terrorists attack the West, it was just a small group of outsiders.
If a lone gunman attacks children, it shows the dangers of right-wing groups and must be investigated.
That is our starting point. Just to be clear.

"Beats having to think about the same dead guy everyday."